Current:Home > Finance2 brothers condemned to die for the ‘Wichita massacre’ want a new sentencing hearing -NextWave Wealth Hub
2 brothers condemned to die for the ‘Wichita massacre’ want a new sentencing hearing
View
Date:2025-04-17 22:22:14
Attorneys for two brothers who were sentenced to die in a quadruple killing known as the “Wichita massacre” will argue Monday for a formal resentencing hearing, the latest in a long series of appeals.
How the sentencing was handled has long been a point of contention because the two brothers — Jonathan and Reginald Carr — had a joint hearing when jurors considered their punishments. Prosecutors plan to oppose the latest effort.
The prosecution has long argued that the brothers broke into a home in December 2000 and forced the three men and two women there to have sex with one another and later to withdraw money from ATMs. Jonathan Carr was 20 and Reginald Carr was 23 when the murders occurred; they are now 44 and 46, and both are incarcerated at the state’s maximum-security prison in El Dorado, about 30 miles (48 kilometers) northeast of Wichita.
According to authorities, the women were raped repeatedly before all five victims were taken to a soccer field and shot. Four of them died: Aaron Sander, 29; Brad Heyka, 27; Jason Befort, 26; and Heather Muller, 25. The woman who survived testified against the Carr brothers. They were also convicted of killing another person in a separate attack.
Each of the brothers accused the other of carrying out the crimes.
Kansas has nine men on death row, but the state has not executed anyone since the murderous duo James Latham and George York were hanged on the same day in June 1965.
Attorneys for both brothers raised concerns in the latest round of court filings that the trial attorneys were ineffective — Reginald Carr’s defense said they were “egregiously” so — and failed to aggressively push for a continuance to give themselves more time to prepare. They also agreed that prospective jurors weren’t properly questioned about racial biases. The brothers are Black, their victims white.
Reginald Carr’s attorney’s also brought up an investigation into members of the Wichita Police Department exchanging racist, sexist and homophobic texts and images. Several were ultimately disciplined, and Carr’s attorney wrote that one of them was involved in the investigation of the brothers.
From there, the attorneys for the brothers deviate in their court filings. Jonathan Carr’s attorneys argued that the trial attorneys failed to investigate and present evidence that Reginald Carr, who is older, had a powerful influence over his younger brother and sexually abused him. A Kansas Department of Correction evaluation conducted just days after Jonathan Carr was sentenced to death said he “appears to idolize his brother,” his attorneys wrote.
Meanwhile, Reginald Carr’s attorneys wrote the trial attorneys were unprepared to rebut Jonathan’s defense, which it described as “largely consisting of family members prepped to promote saving Jonathan Carr’s life over his older brother’s life.” And they further argued that DNA evidence and identification was actually stronger against Jonathan Carr.
Last year, the U.S. Supreme Court refused to request a formal resentencing hearing for each defendant. That action came a little less than a year after the Kansas Supreme Court ruled that the two brothers had received fair trials and upheld their death sentences.
The Kansas court upheld their convictions in 2014 but overturned their death sentences, concluding that not having separate hearings violated the U.S. Constitution. The U.S. Supreme Court reversed that decision in 2016, returning the case to the Kansas Supreme Court.
When the Kansas Supreme Court took up the brothers’ cases again, their attorneys raised questions about how their cases weren’t conducted separately when jurors were considering whether the death penalty was warranted. Other issues they raised included the instructions that were given to jurors and how closing arguments were conducted.
The Kansas court’s majority concluded that while the lower-court judge and prosecutors made errors, those errors did not warrant overturning their death sentences again.
veryGood! (99)
Related
- Macy's says employee who allegedly hid $150 million in expenses had no major 'impact'
- Ruby slippers from ‘The Wizard of Oz’ are for sale nearly 2 decades after they were stolen
- Connecticut to decide on constitution change to make mail-in voting easier
- Beyoncé Channels Pamela Anderson in Surprise Music Video for Bodyguard
- Nearly 400 USAID contract employees laid off in wake of Trump's 'stop work' order
- 3-term Democrat Sherrod Brown tries to hold key US Senate seat in expensive race
- Ready to spend retirement savings? What to know about a formula for safe withdrawals
- Utah Gov. Spencer Cox is expected to win reelection after his surprising endorsement of Trump
- Megan Fox's ex Brian Austin Green tells Machine Gun Kelly to 'grow up'
- The top US House races in Oregon garnering national attention
Ranking
- Louvre will undergo expansion and restoration project, Macron says
- Jaw-Dropping Amazon Fashion Deals: 3 Long-Sleeve Shirts for $19, Plus Up to 69% Off Fall Styles
- Lisa Blunt Rochester could make history with a victory in Delaware’s US Senate race
- Republican Mike Braun faces Republican-turned-Democrat Jennifer McCormick in Indiana governor’s race
- Woman dies after Singapore family of 3 gets into accident in Taiwan
- The GOP expects to keep Kansas’ open House seat. Democratic Rep. Davids looks tough to beat
- Lisa Blunt Rochester could make history with a victory in Delaware’s US Senate race
- Jonathan Haze, who played Seymour in 'The Little Shop of Horrors,' dies at 95: Reports
Recommendation
Appeals court scraps Nasdaq boardroom diversity rules in latest DEI setback
People — and salmon — return to restored Klamath to celebrate removal of 4 dams
Central Michigan voters are deciding 2 open congressional seats in the fight for the US House
Add These Kate Spade Outlet Early Black Friday Deals to Your Cart STAT – $51 Bags & Finds Start at $11
IRS recovers $4.7 billion in back taxes and braces for cuts with Trump and GOP in power
The top US House races in Oregon garnering national attention
Another round of powerful, dry winds to raise wildfire risk across California
After Disasters, Whites Gain Wealth, While People of Color Lose, Research Shows